top of page

Political Notes: The Aftermath

Nov 13
5 min read

by Jon Fuhrman


Tuesday, November 10. So you thought it was all over. Well, not so fast. All sorts of races are still dangling out there.


Make no mistake, though. They’re all icing on the cake. No change will impact the overwhelming repudiation by the voting public of President Trump’s Administration and the Republican Party writ large.


Here’s just one small example of the stunning depth of the anger voters displayed. A reader of the Electoral-Vote.com blog reported in from Tarrant County, Texas (the greater Ft. Worth area). The reader noted that about half the judges in Tarrant’s civil, criminal, probate and family courts ran unopposed (because Republicans had been so dominant in the county). But every single Republican candidate who had an opponent lost their race, by nearly identical 55%-45% margins. It seemed that voters had decided that no Republican, regardless of their personal characteristics or record, and regardless of the fact that these judges have no political decision-making authority, would get their vote.


Of the national races still undecided, the premier cases are the two Senate races. Scott Colom, in Mississippi, now leads by over 2,500 votes with 97% of the votes counted. There are still absentee votes that might arrive, and there are lots of “affidavit ballots”, Mississippi’s version of our provisional ballots, not yet counted or not yet verified. Mississippi’s Republican Secretary of State, in an effort to “clean up” their voter rolls, pushed into “inactive” status anyone who didn’t match up on lists they got from the major credit bureaus of people who had recent credit activity at their given address. Well, lots of people who showed up to vote, and had been living at their same address for decades, were shocked to find themselves now designated as inactive voters. They were allowed to vote using the “affidavit” ballots, but those ballots also required the voters provide proof of identity. If the voter didn’t happen to have their driver license or passport with them that day, they were given a week to bring that proof to their local county registrar’s office.


Not surprisingly, those voters were predominantly lower income voters, and Colom voters, so as affidavit ballots slowly got validated and counted, Colom’s majority has been steadily growing. Pretty much all the pundits are predicting Colom will, indeed, be the 55th Democratic Senator. Colom is, however, starting to express his frustration with the pundit class. He noted that as people like Cook consistently rated his seat Safe Republican, it became a self-fulfilling prophecy – if Colom has no chance, he can’t raise money, and if he can’t raise money, he has no chance. It was only in the last couple of weeks that Cook grudgingly moved the race to the Likely Republican category. But in the end, it will be Colom sitting in the Senate in an historic upset for Mississippi. (Indeed, by the time you read this column, the race may well have been called for Colom.)


Alaska is more of a puzzle, with Mary Peltola extending her lead to nearly 2,500 votes, but almost a quarter of the total vote is still outstanding. Further, with Alaska’s ranked choice voting system, if no candidate gets 50%+1 of the vote, then they begin allocating votes to a voter’s second, third or fourth choice. But the outstanding ballots seem to be largely from rural areas, where Peltola polls strongly, rather than from Anchorage or Juneau or Fairbanks. So my guess is that, while the process may take another two weeks, Peltola will be our 56th Democratic Senator.


There are also House races yet to be called. In two Louisiana districts, there will be run-off elections (in early December) because no candidate won a 50% majority. Each district will have one Democrat and one Republican running; given the environment, the Democratic candidates might have a chance, although the votes cast for all the Republican candidates in each race far outpaced the total votes cast for all the Democratic candidates in that race.

Other House seats remain too close to call. Cong. Virginia Foxx, who chaired the Rules Committee in this Congress (one of the most powerful positions in the House) now leads her Democratic opponent by 38 votes out of 280,000 ballots cast. Two Democrats have leads of about 300 votes each, and another Republican is ahead by a mere 41 votes.


Regardless of those outcomes, though, Democrats have a solid 256 seats – a 41 seat gain – with the possibility of a few more added on for good measure. What that means, in practical terms, is that Hakeem Jeffries will be the next Speaker, and he will have a relatively free hand to steer the caucus. There may be a few DSA loyalists or Squad members who won’t sign on to particular bills, but Jeffries will have the luxury of graciously allowing them to diverge, knowing that it will make no difference in the outcome. Nor will any of the threats or protestations from the left make any difference at all, or move any caucus members at all. Democrats are ecstatic with the majority Jeffries delivered and the practical power which that majority brings, from committee and sub-committee chairmanships to legislative initiatives to dominating the public relations sphere.


All that notwithstanding, where will Democrats go now that they control the Congress? What decisions will they face in the short-term, and then the longer term?


In the Senate, other than electing Sen. Schumer as Majority Leader, perhaps the most telling first move will be deciding on the Senate’s rules, and in particular, the filibuster rule. Now it takes 60 affirmative votes to close debate; but that’s sort of a misnomer, because it’s not so much debate as the mere threat of debate. The minority can just say we want to debate a bill; if the majority doesn’t have 60 votes, the de facto result is tabling the bill and just moving on. Now, this rule, to be fair, did indeed save us Democrats from some pretty terrible legislation. The Voter ID bill is a prime example. Were it not for the filibuster rule, it would have been law last spring and potentially impacted this mid-term election. On the other hand, it also obstructed a fair bit of critical legislation Democratic majorities wanted to pass, on civil rights, voting rights, on safety net funding. So what will we do?


The Senate can, by simple majority vote, change or rewrite its rules at the beginning of each session, so this decision will be coming up in early January. Some long-time veteran Democratic Senators may be reluctant to give up this guard-rail, pointing to the potential damage Trump sought to impose that was blocked. Newer Senators are likely to be less patient, and perhaps less risk-averse. Indeed, looking at the 2028 and 2030 Senate elections, it seems difficult to imagine a scenario where Republicans gain back control of the Senate before 2032. So eliminating the filibuster rule might set the scene for major legislative progress after the election of a Democratic President in 2028.


Or, the Senate might seek a compromise: reducing the 60 vote threshold to 55 votes (especially if we have 56 Democrats), or requiring that a filibuster involve a Senator (or Senators) actually standing up on the Senate floor and talking for hours on end (a la Jimmy Stewart in “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington”), or instead of requiring 60 affirmative votes, requiring 40 negative votes, so that a single Senator can’t gum up the works.


My guess is that, with pressure from newly-elected Senators and other junior caucus members, the Senate will eliminate the filibuster and move to a system more like the House, where leadership controls which legislation moves to the floor, and, after some standard number of hours for debate, a simple majority can move the legislation along. Some might declaim the death of the Senate as the great deliberative body, but others may rejoice that, simply put, now we can just get things done!

Recent Posts

See All
Dem’s Win is Broad and Deep – Very, Very Deep

Political Notes: Special Post-Election Edition by Jon Fuhrman Thursday, Nov. 5. It’s over, finally. All the waiting, all the worrying, all the hand-wringing and the prognosticating. Now, we get to sa

 
 
 
After We Win in November, What Happens Then?

Political Notes by Jon Fuhrman Wednesday, September 9. As Republicans gather today and tomorrow in Dallas for their mid-term convention (aka All Praise Donald Trump), Democrats are not so quietly awai

 
 
 

Comments


All Rights Reserved | Website designed by LAMPP

bottom of page