Dem’s Win is Broad and Deep – Very, Very Deep
Political Notes: Special Post-Election Edition
by Jon Fuhrman
Thursday, Nov. 5. It’s over, finally. All the waiting, all the worrying, all the hand-wringing and the prognosticating. Now, we get to savor the victory – practically an unconditional surrender. Well, except for Florida, and there are actually some hopeful signs even in Florida.
You know already that we won across the country, from Maine to Washington State (and maybe even Alaska), from Michigan down to Texas. Senate races that were supposed to be nail-biters were, in fact, solid or overwhelming wins: Talarico by 8%, El-Sayed by 8%, Jackson by 6%, Hamilton by 5% (in KANSAS, of all places). And then our stars of the night: Cooper by 20% and Ossoff by 18%, in states President Trump carried easily in 2024. Even in Mississippi, as I write, Scott Colom’s lead has grown to over 1,800 votes, enough likely to make him our 55th Democratic Senator.
On the House side, it was even more lop-sided. As I write this, we’re at 253 seats officially called, with another 5 seats where Democrats lead by 1% or more, and yet another 5 seats where Dems lead by less than 1%, and one final seat in Louisiana that is headed to a run-off in early December where the Democrat has a slim lead. Moreover, there are 5 seats where the Republican candidate has a lead of under 1%. So we are likely looking at a final count above 260 when all the smoke clears – an astounding 45 seat gain.
Of course, that’s not so astounding when you tally up the nationwide Congressional vote. It swung from 2024 by about 13%, well above most polling estimates and one of the highest mid-term swings in history. This was shocking to most pundits, but on another level, it’s hardly surprising. The war (and we are indeed actually in a war with Iran, the President’s musings notwithstanding) has wreaked havoc with our economy, our alliances, and international stability. The tariffs and trade wars are compounding the damage. The President, after spending a month insisting that people consider him to be on the ballot, spent the last few days focused on the Reflecting Pool and his Triumphal Arch and his new ballroom, surely topics dominating most kitchen tables.
But I don’t think the media has done a good enough job focusing on the depth of the Big Beautiful Blue Blowout. Look at Texas, Georgia and Ohio as three prime examples.
In Texas, we celebrated not merely James Talarico winning the Senate (by defeating that odious Ken Paxton) and Gina Hinojosa defeating three-term Greg Abbott for the Governorship, but success all the way down the ticket, to every statewide office on the ballot. We won the Lt. Governorship, which in Texas is a remarkably powerful post: not only does the Lt. Gov. preside over the State Senate, she (Vikki Goodwin, who defeated the incumbent Dan Patrick) appoints Senators to all the committees and assigns each new bill to whichever committee she deems appropriate, powers typically belonging to a Majority Leader in a State Senate. Further, Democrat Nathan Johnson was elected as the new Attorney-General, replacing Ken Paxton. Going even further, Democrats were elected as the Agricultural Commissioner, the Land Commissioner and the Comptroller. Still continuing, three Democrats were elected to the nine member Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, their highest court for criminal matters, beating one GOP incumbent and two GOP contenders. Also, four Democrats were elected to the nine member Texas Supreme Court, their highest court for civil matters, beating four GOP incumbents. A Democrat defeated a truly repulsive, blatantly prejudiced Republican for a six year term on the Railroad Commission, which in Texas regulates, not railroads, but the entire oil and gas industry; he will join two other GOP Commissioners, so control of the Commission will have to wait until 2028.
Last, but surely not least, Democrats won control of the Texas House of Representatives, the lower house of the state legislature, and picked up one seat in the State Senate. Their Congressional delegation had 13 Democrats; after their “dummymander” (or, as one wit said, their “moron-mander”), Democrats ended up with 14 seats. Winning control of the Texas House was due, in no small part (in addition to Talarico and Hinojosa) to Beto O’Rourke, whose PAC worked to ensure that we had a Democrat running in every single legislative seat – a strategy that lets you take full advantage of the occasional wave election. This was a key to winning control of the Virginia lower house back in 2017, and has led to significant legislative gains everywhere it has been successfully implemented.
Overall, this is not just a repudiation of pathetic candidates like Ken Paxton, or just of the President and an inexplicable war. This is a deep, collective dismissal of the Republican brand, throughout the state, across all ethnic and age lines.
Can the Reps recover? Will they get their game back in 2028? Not with JD Vance, surely. Maybe not even with Marco Rubio, who has stayed very much away from the front lines during the midterm. Ron DeSantis thinks he might be the next candidate, given how Florida escaped the worst of the bloodbath. But he’ll have a long way to go.
And it’s not just Texas! Let’s look at Georgia. Jon Ossoff, of course, cleared the field with an 18% margin. A year ago, folks would have bet it would be 18%, but in the other direction. Then, not only did Keisha Lance Bottoms win by over 8%, but Democrats were elected as the Lt. Gov., Attorney-General, Agriculture Commissioner, Labor Commissioner, Insurance Commissioner, School Superintendent and, perhaps critically, as Secretary of State. (Remember how the Republican Secretary of State, Brad Raffensperger, stood up to Pres. Trump and refused to “find” an extra 11,000 votes for him. Brad, for his courage, was discarded by the GOP, not even making it into the run-off election for the GOP Gubernatorial nomination.) Now there will be Democrat in charge of elections in 2028 (and in many other states as well!). Further, two Democrats were elected to the state’s Public Utility Commission, giving Dems a majority on the Commission and the ability substantially to weigh in on data center siting and their use of electricity, and on utility billings generally. Democrats flipped three seats in the State Senate, leaving them one seat short of a majority, but in the State House, where 91 votes is a majority, Dems have won 90 seats so far (a pick-up of 9 seats), with 3 seats not yet called, but Dems are leading in each of those 3 seats, so it seems a pretty good chance that Dems will gain a majority in the lower house (for the first time since 2004).
Once again, this is not just a repudiation of a candidate tinged with blatant racism, as Mike Collins was, or a drop-in billionaire financing his own campaign (as Rick Jackson did). The state turned against the entire Republican brand, with down ballot candidates actually doing slightly better than Bottoms.
Finally, let’s look at Ohio, where, admittedly, things were a little closer. Gov.-elect Amy Acton actually led the ticket, winning by just under 8%, with Sherrod Brown trailing with “just” a 6% victory margin. In Ohio, the Gov. and Lt. Gov. run as a single ticket, so our Lt. Gov. candidate was automatically elected. But Dems also won the Attorney-General spot, the Treasurer, and, critically, the Secretary of State slots. The current Republican Sec. of State, Frank LaRose, was termed out, but he ran for State Auditor and did win that race. We picked up 3 Congressional seats but, while Dems picked up one seat in the State Senate and 3 – 4 seats in the State House, Reps will still control both chambers, though without enough votes to override gubernatorial vetoes.
More importantly, the depth of our gains weren’t limited to these three states. We defeated election-denying candidates for Secretary of State in Nevada, Arizona, Michigan, and Wisconsin. We flipped BOTH houses of the State Legislature in Arizona and Wisconsin, and flipped the one house we didn’t control in Pennsylvania, Michigan and Minnesota. All told, Democrats flipped 300 individual state legislative seats around the country, a showing reminiscent of 2010 – but in the opposite direction, of course. These seats, and control of the legislatures, will be critical in 2028, to ensure fair and safe elections, and after 2030, to ensure fair reapportionments. We also won State Supreme Court seats in multiple states, further strengthening our ability to ensure fair future elections.
So all in all, it was quite a night.
Before closing, I want to point out one other significant change in the landscape. GOP election-deniers and troublemakers were confident that, if they interfered with the Electoral College certifying the vote, that they would ultimately win. That’s because the Constitution assigns to the House of Representatives the task of choosing the President, if the Electoral College, for whatever reason, cannot do so. But the House votes, not by individual Representatives, but by State: the delegates for each state choose, by majority vote, for whom their State will vote. Under the current Congress, and the last several Congresses, the Republicans controlled a majority of State delegations, in large part due to their control of smaller states and southern states. States like South Dakota, and North Dakota and Wyoming all got one vote; California and New York also each get one vote, under this system.
Well, no more. Whereas the GOP controlled 30 state delegations in the current Congress, with 18 for the Dems and two states with evenly split delegations, in the new Congress Democrats control 24 state delegations, Republicans control 23 delegations, and 3 (Maine, Montana and Wisconsin) are tied. If the House cannot, by a majority of state delegations, choose a President, then the Vice-President, chosen by the Senate, becomes President.
So there is no longer any incentive, no “security blanket,” for the election deniers or troublemakers. Even if they succeed, a Democrat likely becomes President. This may take much of the fuel out of that particular dumpster fire, and our democracy is further insulated from their craziness.
And, by the way, the election happened, basically with no muss, no fuss, no federal interference, no seized ballots or accusations of space lasers (except for Elon, who commented that apparently his space lasers didn’t work this time). How ordinary, and yet how extraordinary.
Comments